Welcome, Guest. Please Login or Register.
Plagiarism Detector Support Forum
09/07/10 at 01:43:21
News:
Home Help Search Login Register


Pages: 1
Send Topic Print
THE PROGRAM DOES NOT WORK!!!! (Read 1052 times)
irritated
YaBB Newbies
*




Posts: 5
THE PROGRAM DOES NOT WORK!!!!
12/29/09 at 06:14:25
 
I have recently purchased the Pro version of this application. Upon testing I have found the following issues  
 
a) When testing the same uploaded MS word document on four occasions the resulting reports were markedly different - why?
 
b) After making a self compiled plagiarised report from 5 different websites. Only one of these "copied & pasted" paragraphs was detected the others were coded GREEN - Why?  
 
This is way lower than the 97% accuracy rate described. No settings were changed and the performance level was set at "advanced check" for each check. Can this be explained rationally or is the program defective?
 
As a school Principal I have to be certain of the credentials of this program - at present it has a very big question mark over its capabilities!!!!!!!!!!
Back to top
 
 
  IP Logged
Mike Sanders - PDSupport
YaBB Administrator
*****


I will help! :-)

Posts: 292
Gender: male
Re: THE PROGRAM DOES NOT WORK!!!!
Reply #1 - 12/29/09 at 07:03:35
 
Please provide us with the document under consideration so we could make all the tests needed to provide adequate support. Mail to support[_at_]plagiarism-detector.com
 
We do not store any documents after such tests are done, neither we distribute or use them any other way.
I guarantee that we will completely destroy the documents after the test.
 
Looking forward to your reply!
Back to top
 
« Last Edit: 12/29/09 at 08:38:48 by Mike Sanders - PDSupport »  

The Administrator.
WWW 204331133   IP Logged
irritated
YaBB Newbies
*




Posts: 5
Re: THE PROGRAM DOES NOT WORK!!!!
Reply #2 - 12/31/09 at 02:29:38
 
I would prefer a refund to my credit card please. This program cannot be viewed as reliable for its stated purpose when one student's work gets four different results, and one purposfully plagiarised document does not have the content detected as plagiarised (despite the fact that it was copied and pasted directly from a website). When assessing student plagiarism we need to be as fair as possible. At present this lacks consistency, and therefore fairness - in education this is not acceptable. Additionally, we do not have the time to forward individual student files for checking.
Back to top
 
 
  IP Logged
Mike Sanders - PDSupport
YaBB Administrator
*****


I will help! :-)

Posts: 292
Gender: male
Re: THE PROGRAM DOES NOT WORK!!!!
Reply #3 - 01/04/10 at 06:05:49
 
Hello,
 
As long as we are not able to verify the results you have - we are not able to help you.
 
To reproduce the results you experience - I need to have either the documents you are checking or the originality
reports generated (better both).
 
Could you please email me the TEST DOCUMENT you have compiled to test PD?
 
Thus I will be able to check myself to prove your words!
 
No problem with a refund but please - provide your First Name and Second Name.
 
Looking forward to your reply!
Back to top
 
 

The Administrator.
WWW 204331133   IP Logged
irritated
YaBB Newbies
*




Posts: 5
Re: THE PROGRAM DOES NOT WORK!!!!
Reply #4 - 01/04/10 at 06:08:45
 
Name = Tony Fynn (Please refund ASAP).
Back to top
 
 
  IP Logged
irritated
YaBB Newbies
*




Posts: 5
Re: THE PROGRAM DOES NOT WORK!!!!
Reply #5 - 01/04/10 at 06:35:17
 
I've tried uploading the requested docs - invalid file format given for both sampled document and the report. Please supply an email contact and I will send them to you. In the meantime please refund my CC.
Back to top
 
 
  IP Logged
Mike Sanders - PDSupport
YaBB Administrator
*****


I will help! :-)

Posts: 292
Gender: male
Re: THE PROGRAM DOES NOT WORK!!!!
Reply #6 - 01/04/10 at 15:03:55
 
E-mail provided in the Private Meassafe on this forum. We will contact you about the refund shortly after we receive the documents.
 
Thank you for your patience.
Back to top
 
 

The Administrator.
WWW 204331133   IP Logged
irritated
YaBB Newbies
*




Posts: 5
Re: THE PROGRAM DOES NOT WORK!!!!
Reply #7 - 01/04/10 at 21:14:44
 
I have submitted the two documents (results and plagiarised doc) to Plagiarism Detector Support Forum [***]. You will see the results on "advanced setting"
 
a) 0% plagiarised  
b) 39% original
c) 61% quoted.  
 
This is totally incorrect. All the document was copied and pasted from two sources. The upper part from a) and the second paragraph from (b)
 
a) http://answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20090214190532AAFhvbn
b) http://www.nutritiondata.com/facts/foods-from-wienerschnitzel/7124/2
 
The document entitled "The Poor Fellow" is 100% plagiarised.
Back to top
 
« Last Edit: 01/05/10 at 11:25:07 by Mike Sanders - PDSupport »  
  IP Logged
Mike Sanders - PDSupport
YaBB Administrator
*****


I will help! :-)

Posts: 292
Gender: male
Re: THE PROGRAM DOES NOT WORK!!!!
Reply #8 - 01/07/10 at 10:32:36
 
Hello,
 
I've issued a refund per your request.
 
Secondly - judging by the values on your previous post - I'm afraid that you do not quite understand Plagiarism Detector
logics.
 
Apart from marking Plagiarism Plagiarism Detector also marks "referenced" part. Any SIMILAR part is considered
referenced if at least one hyperlink points to the source. In your experiment "61% quoted" means that you HAVE NOT removed
the hyper links from the text. THAT IS WHY Plagiarism Detector shows 0% Plagiarism and 61% quoted.
 
In case you remove the hyperlinks it will show 61% Plagiarism or even more (PD ha a sophisticated method to heuristically detect "linked" fragments)
 
Unfortunately I have not received the e-mail with your test document  Sad.
 
The last thing to say - Plagiarism Detector may show DIFFERENT percentage on the same source and there IS a good reason for this -
Every time a request goes to the Search Engine this is an asynchronous reuest - that is they return in different time,
thus the final similarity matrix may be SLIGHTLY different at each rescan.
 
Theoretically, if for some reason a critically important source fails (due to the request timeout or a search engine timeout)
this may cause the whole document to be reported as 100% green.
 
Still - this is a general plagiarism detection issue - it is not a bug in any respect. In case you find any program doing it  
better - feel free to post a note here - our RnD and I will have a closer look at it.
 
By the way - currently our RnD is working at the high precision cache mechanism that will
slightly aid the problem of missed out source, but I repeat that this is more a theoretical problem than a technical bug.
 
So far I believe that Plagiarism Detector is the best software available.
Good luck!
Back to top
 
 

The Administrator.
WWW 204331133   IP Logged
Eugen
YaBB Newbies
*




Posts: 29
Gender: male
Re: THE PROGRAM DOES NOT WORK!!!!
Reply #9 - 01/12/10 at 01:05:54
 
I confirm this - there is no other software on the market today performing better. I made several hundreds of documents checks (automatic with PD and manually) and I found similar results. Of course, anyone may feel the interface is not as good as desired or other small improvements are necessary. But, per total, it is the best available software for checking against plagiarism.
 
P.S. I've made a DOC with the information from the two links provided and the report is as follows:
 
Top 3 Plagiarism Sources:
2497 http://answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20090214190532AAFhvbn  
1742 http://www.scribd.com/doc/23739170/roselleblog  
1604 http://www.nutritiondata.com/facts/foods-from-wienerschnitzel/7124/2  
 
Original - 22% / 78% - Plagiarism  
Referenced 0% / Linked 0%  
 
It is not 100% plagiarism because of different formating for DOC and HTML file on the Internet.
 
The user is "Irritated" for nothing ...
Back to top
 
 
  IP Logged
Pages: 1
Send Topic Print